Sunday, March 7, 2021

My March through the FamilySearch Family Tree: Day 7 (my paternal grandfather's maternal-side ancestors)

The only part of my paternal-side family tree left to deal with on the FamilySearch Family Tree is the maternal side of my paternal grandfather. The Bannons and the Hylands originated in County Laois, Ireland, and then left Ireland for Oldbury in England, before some of them left to come to Newark, New Jersey. After the Bannons and Hylands arrived in England, William Bannon and Mary Ann Hyland married (as did his sister and her brother).

William Bannon: https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/KV1S-N8F

Mary Ann Hyland: https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/KV1S-N8N

I couldn't find any duplicates for either, so I moved on to their parents (William Bannon and his wife Mary, and James Hyland and Catherine Delaney).

I couldn't find any evidence of William (the older) and his wife Mary in the FS Family Tree, so I added them:

William Bannon: https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/GHBK-V8J

Mary: https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/GHBV-L6N

Finally, there are Mary Ann Hyland's parents, James Hyland and Catherine Delaney:

James Hyland: https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/GHBQ-XCC

Catherine Delaney: https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/research-help/GH3V-P53

And here is where things got a little tricky. Someone already had a James Hyland and a Catherine Delaney in the tree, but with a child in Wisconsin. This made no sense, as James and Catherine left County Laois (also known as Queen's County, Ireland) for England, but never came to the United States. So there is some confusion here. I disconnected that child from my James Hyland and Catherine Delaney (I suppose there could have been more than one couple with the same names).

And with that, at the end of Week 1, I completed cleaning up my paternal-side family on the FamilySearch Family Tree.

Saturday, March 6, 2021

My March through the FamilySearch Family Tree: Day 6 (my paternal grandfather's paternal grandmother)

Time to tackle the Reilly ancestry, although it's limited to my great-great-grandmother, Mary Ann Reilly, born 1829 in County Cavan, Ireland and died 1897 in Newark, New Jersey:

https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/L8RY-J7J

No duplicates suggested or found, and so I spent my time reviewing and attaching a lot of sources that FamilySearch suggested (primarily either census records or birth records for her children). 

One surprise: A final child who did not appear to survive more than 3 years at most, and the only daughter born to Mary Ann out of 9 children. I did not have this daughter in my tree, and now I do.

There was also a marriage record attached to Mary Ann presumably for her son, John, but the middle initial for John didn't match and Mary Ann's son John was long dead by the time of the marriage of the John in the record. So I detached that one and explained why.

Tomorrow, it's on to the Bannons and the Hylands!

Friday, March 5, 2021

My March through the FamilySearch Family Tree: Day 5 (my paternal grandfather and his Smith ancestors)

If I were to go only by my experiences with my paternal grandmother's family, I would come to the conclusion that it is easy to clean up my direct ancestors on the FamilySearch Family Tree. But I realize that I may have very few relatives on that particular line, so none of them would have created unnecessary duplicates or added incorrect people to the families (although I do need to do a little cleanup on my grandmother's siblings).

Today I'm going to tackle something a bit more challenging: my Irish ancestors through my paternal grandfather, including Smith, Bannon, Hyland, and Reilly. I expect this will be more complicated but more enlightening as to the issues dealing with a collaborative family tree.

My paternal grandfather was William Henry Smith, born 1889 in Newark, New Jersey and died 1961:

https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/L8RT-F7L

At some point, I'll need to add his children other than my father, but I'll leave that for now and focus only on him and his ancestors. I didn't notice any duplicates for him, so I'll keep with the Smith line and move on to his father, Charles Henry Smith, born 1859 in Newark, died 1906.

https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/9N8S-KR9

No problems there, and no obvious duplicates. We move on to his father (my great-great-grandfather), James Smith, born about 1825 in County Cavan, Ireland, died 1872 in Newark.

https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/L8RY-JSG

FamilySearch suggests one possible duplicate, based on an 1871 John Smyth born to a James Smyth and Mary Reilly in Ireland. But since my James Smith left Ireland in 1842 and his last child was born in 1867 in Newark, I have marked the suggested duplicate as not a match.

Finally, James Smith was the son of Philip Smith and Catherine (surname unknown), so I will need to add those to the tree. 

Philip: https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/GHBS-S92

Catherine: https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/GHB9-18W

And with that, I'm done with the direct Smith ancestral line (I'm sure I'll need to do some checking on the Smith descendants). 

I'll save the Bannon, Hyland, and Reilly lines for tomorrow.

Thursday, March 4, 2021

My March through the FamilySearch Family Tree: Day 4 (my paternal grandmother's grandparents)

So far, I've run into minimal problems with cleaning up a few duplicates for my paternal grandmother and her parents. So I want to finish his ancestry by taking on her grandparents (I don't have any research myself that goes any farther back than that). 

Rachel's paternal grandparents are Mendel Weinglass and Frumat "Fanny" Zorkel, and her maternal grandparents are Anschel Grodowitz and Hannah "Annie" Siegel. All 4 appear in the FamilySearch Family Tree here:

Mendel Weinglass: https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/9ZMC-NBJ

Frumat "Fanny" Zorkel: https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/9ZMC-NBV

Anschel Grodowitz: https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/L6KM-14C

Hannah "Annie" Siegel: https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/L6KM-1HH

I was not previously following Anschel and Hannah, so I fixed that, and I fixed Hannah's surname. 

And that appears to be it. No duplicates here. That means I'm finished with checking on my paternal grandmother's ancestry (although there are still fixes to be done to her siblings and others).

Next up tomorrow: I begin to tackle my Irish ancestors (the Smiths, Bannons, Reillys, and Hylands). This should prove much more complex, and I suspect, educational.

Wednesday, March 3, 2021

My March through the FamilySearch Family Tree: Day 3 (my paternal grandmother's parents)

 I started this march through the FamilySearch Family Tree two days ago with my parents (no fixes needed to be made) and yesterday on to my paternal grandmother (merging two duplicates into her record). Now it's time to move to her parents, Louis Weinglass and Sarah Grodowitz.  

Great-grandfather Louis Weinglass (what I would consider my official entry for him) is here:

https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/MY5Z-SRG

I will eventually need to clean up some duplicates for his children, but I don't want to lose focus on Louis himself (and then his wife, my great-grandmother Sarah Grodowitz). 

So I first merged a record for a person named Luy Weinglass for his daughter Anna's birth. Then I merged the same incorrectly transcribed Louis Heinglas that was part of another birth record.

That seems to have taken care of Louis. On to Sarah.

https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/MY5Z-STQ

As for Sarah, the Fanny in Anna's birth record has to be her, and of course, the Sarah Heinglas whose surname was mistranscribed. So I'll merge them the same way I did for Louis.

That went quickly, including adding many of the sources that were linked to the duplicates.

Next up, Louis' parents.

Tuesday, March 2, 2021

My March through the FamilySearch Family Tree: Day 2 (my paternal grandmother)

Yesterday I explained what I have set out to do this month, and why. I've reviewed the entries for my parents (no duplications and the facts appear to be correct). Today I move into my grandparents' generation.

When I first began researching my family back in 1992, I realized that there were some big differences among my grandparents. 3 of the 4 had extremely common surnames: Smith, Martin, and King. Smith is acknowledged as the most common surname in English-speaking countries, and Martin and King both appear among the 100 most common surnames in the United States as of the 2010 census (Martin is ranked 20th, King is ranked 34th).

This means that, unless my ancestors all have very unusual first names, I'm going to be working through a lot of possible duplicates in my Smith, Martin, and King lines. But that leaves my 4th ancestral line, that of my paternal grandmother: Weinglass. The Weinglass family is also the last one to arrive in the United States (in the 1870s), and so I would expect to see fewer duplicates and other problems. So let's begin with Rachel Weinglass, my paternal grandmother.

A search for Rachel Weinglass in the Family Tree gets a large number of hits, although I would get far fewer if I marked the search fields as "Match All Exactly". I can also slide the switch to Show Exact Searching Fields, which gives me a checkbox for each field.

The first result is my grandmother's cousin, also named Rachel Weinglass (my grandmother's father was Louis, her cousin's father was Harris). The second entry is my grandmother:

https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/MY5Z-SR6

I am already following her entry. As I continue to scroll down the list, I see a number of other individuals, including my grandmother's siblings. Then I get to one for Ray Weinglass. Same parents, and I know that my grandmother went by "Ray" as her nickname. So I decide to merge this person into the entry for my grandmother, using the Merge By ID option in the right-hand menu. It warns me:

"Merging is a complex process in which you decide if two people are the same person. If they are, you choose which information should be kept. Please take the time necessary to carefully review each possible duplicate."

I enter the ID for my grandmother (the one you see in the URL above) and click Continue. I now see the profiles side by side.

Because I was looking at Ray when I chose to do the merge, it lists Rachel as the duplicate and Ray as the surviving profile. It will keep Ray and delete Rachel, which is the opposite of what I want. Fortunately, there is a Switch button at the top, and when I click it, it explains which profile survives.

I continue, and it shows the details of what will be kept. I click the "Yes Continue" button.

I don't need to bring over any other info from the duplicate profile, and Continue.

In the 3rd and final step, it asks me to provide a reason. I write: "Rachel went by 'Ray' as her nickname. All other details are the same (or very nearly so), including the names of the parents."

I click Finish Merge.

One more step here: I decided to edit her first name so that it reads as: Rachel "Ray", so that it will be clear that it's the same person.

Am I done with my grandmother? Not quite. FamilySearch alerts me to another duplicate, this one with the name Rachel Heinglas. I click on that one. Yup, same person as my grandmother, even with the right parents, but the surname has been incorrectly transcribed as Heinglas. Apparently the info was taken automatically from the New York Births and Christenings collection.

So I merge those, too. (It tries to add her incorrectly transcribed parents, too, but I'll get to them another day.)

That's about it. FamilySearch also warns me that using "Manhattan" is non-standard, so I change her birth location to "New York City". 

Finally, it suggests that I attach her birth record from another collection, so I do. And now I'm done.

Tomorrow, I tackle her parents.

Monday, March 1, 2021

My March through the FamilySearch Family Tree: Day 1 (my parents)

One of the most common discussions in The Genealogy Squad Facebook group revolves around the Family Tree on FamilySearch. Unfortunately, many people seem to associate the word "FamilySearch" only with the Family Tree, ignoring the separate record collections, and as a result, new genealogists may think that they should not use any part of FamilySearch at all.

You can certainly use the records on FamilySearch without ever viewing the Family Tree, and that's what I do 99% of the time. But this month I want to turn my attention specifically to the Family Tree, to dispel any myths about it, and to demonstrate a way to use it in a productive manner.

The FamilySearch Family Tree is a single, collaborative tree. This means that instead of completely separate trees (such as the many public and private trees on Ancestry), there is only one tree that is worked on by anyone who wants to contribute to it. In this way, the Family Tree is structured much like a wiki (like Wikipedia), allowing millions of people to work together to create, add to, and maintain the tree.

The FamilySearch Family Tree is not the only online tree structured in this way. Geni and WikiTree also use a collaborative model to allow users to contribute to the same tree.

The upside to this process is that everyone can focus on the ancestors they know best and contribute information about them to the single tree. But the downside is that people are only human, and make mistakes, and they may add incorrect information to the tree or change correct information to incorrect information. They may connect unrelated individuals or confuse two people who happen to have the same name.

Fortunately, when an error is discovered, it can be corrected. The problem arises when the same error is repeated over time, even changing corrections back to incorrect versions. 

The best solution is to (1) "follow" all individual profiles that you have contributed to, to see if any of them are being changed, (2) add source material to support the facts provided, and (3) politely address any misinformation that is published.

This month, I'm going to run an experiment and see what happens when I go through my own ancestors on the Family Tree, confirming information and correcting any misinformation. 

I've already looked at my own parents, and their information appears correct (or close enough but I could tweak it a bit and add sources):

George Thomas Smith (my father): https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/L8PG-5J8

Altha Corinne Martin (my mother): https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/L8PG-51K

Starting tomorrow, I'll begin work on my grandparents, and I hope that you will come along for my march through the FamilySearch Family Tree.